Kairan1979 posted a comment on Wednesday 18th January 2017 1:20pm for First Year

I certainly understand his dislike of Wizardling world, but I don't think Hermione will be happy to learn about his hatred of Harry, who is oblivously as much of a victim as she was.

reader1writer1 posted a comment on Monday 28th April 2014 8:04pm for First Year

Love it :) I can't wait until you get around to more of this

lwj2 posted a comment on Sunday 11th December 2011 9:13pm for First Year

Interesting, using Dr. Granger's perspective of the wizarding world.

I hope you follow this on, thanks for posting.

bjon66 posted a comment on Friday 9th December 2011 3:18pm for First Year

But, it was for the greater good... lmfao

lwj2 posted a comment on Monday 26th September 2011 2:04pm for First Year

I like this, it's a perspective I've never seen before in the fanfic I've read.

As the father of two girls, I can appreciate Mr. Granger's ... dislike ... of Harry and the wizarding world, I routinely curse at our leaders and the U.S. Marine Corps because my youngest girl and my son are Marines, which I'm proud of and which terrifies me.

I'm looking forward to reading more of this story, thanks for posting it.

sarahgirl12384 posted a comment on Friday 12th August 2011 5:12pm for First Year

Love this one!!! I especially enjoy Hermione's Father's point-of-view!

reader1writer1 posted a comment on Saturday 11th June 2011 2:19pm for First Year

well done. I'm looking for the next bit. :)

Cassandra30 posted a comment on Monday 6th June 2011 9:12pm for First Year

Superb! I agree with Philip Granger!

Flamefoxrose posted a comment on Tuesday 11th January 2011 8:33pm for First Year

Thank you for a well written story from Hermione's father point of view. Poor wizarding world about to get a wake up call.

DrgnMstr posted a comment on Tuesday 14th September 2010 2:19am for First Year

I like it. There's not too much I can say to improve it, but if you could give some reason why Mr. Granger hates Harry Potter, that would be great. I mean, so far it looks like Mr. Granger thinks that Harry was victim in this, but that doesn't jive with him hating the poor lad.

TxA_GunFighter posted a comment on Monday 16th August 2010 12:26pm for First Year

Very good chapter.

gunny

delrusant posted a comment on Tuesday 18th May 2010 10:59am for First Year

external viewpoint and personnal judgement, woulc such article be enough to leave an impression on the bigotted world and will the father hate harry more for leading her into danger or not answering her heart?

princess ducky posted a comment on Sunday 11th April 2010 5:44pm for First Year

This intrigues me. I'm assuming that there is going to be a chapter for each of Hermione's Hogwarts years, am I right?

Looking forward to more, this is different but very well done and I'm enjoying it greatly.

Princess Ducky

Richard P. posted a comment on Thursday 25th March 2010 8:17am for First Year

Loved the beginning. Well written despite your claims of not being a good writer. Hope you continue on with this story really soon.

TheHard posted a comment on Sunday 21st March 2010 2:00am for First Year

Wow, this is something new... are going to be more chapter of this?

Nice chapter

Eric Oppen posted a comment on Saturday 27th February 2010 4:04pm for First Year

This is a good look at what Hermione's father must have been going through, poor man. If I had a daughter like Hermione I'd adore her and it would be an incredible wrench to lose her.

Triggerbox posted a comment on Tuesday 23rd February 2010 1:15pm for First Year

Normally I don't review, but I enjoyed your perspective in this fic. So there you are. You didn't have much dialogue and since this supposed to be a column that is to be expected. The only complaint I could really think of was that you kind of drifted from that perspective sometimes. Though to be honest that didn't bother me that much. So keep up the good work.

Zamia posted a comment on Saturday 20th February 2010 3:24am for First Year

Well said. Pity JKR won't read this and realise how much she stuffed up the later years. Good read. Cheers.
Z

Patches posted a comment on Friday 19th February 2010 4:32am for First Year

This is a very good letter. It sounds like Hermione's father would write a letter like this. From Hermione being mentioned in the past tense I would assume that Hermione did not survive. I look forward to more of this story. Thanks for writing. pms

GremlinXTJ posted a comment on Friday 19th February 2010 2:47am for First Year

Well this is cool.
A whole different and original angle. :D
I hope you will continue your Grangers based stories. ;)